Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tod Cheney's avatar

Ever since I read Jane Kenyon’s poem Otherwise, I’ve thought how I might be otherwise myself. Or going back a ways, might have been otherwise than I was, that got me to this point where I am now, when I’m thinking I might be different, or might have been, and still could be if only. It matters where you start from I guess. We start alone, and add on from there. At least that’s the plan someone wrote. I never gave it much thought. For all the thinking I thought I was doing I never gave anything much thought. Not that changed anything anyway. To get otherwise you have to start somewhere, but that was the mystery, just as any otherwise now is a mystery. Seems like it’s one mystery after another, meanwhile, have a baby, fall in love, circumnavigate mountains and the produce aisle… Other people seem to do it. Like Jane Kenyon and Donald Hall made love and wrote poetry on a Vermont farm until Jane died. The ultimate otherwise there. And Don sat in a blue chair looking out the window at his barn and fields, until finally, he died. Or are all the others only illusion? What otherwise, I ask, would be anything other than this self same old mystery, and I don’t have an answer.

Wim's avatar

I have no regrets - that’s what I say when the subject comes up. I say it out of philosophical conviction. I believe we are born with certain karma and what we do and what happens to us is what’s fated to happen. My brain believes this but my heart isn’t buying it. For example, I deeply regret that I lacked courage with the opposite sex. I was so shy, so terrified of being rejected, that I took no initiative. In fact, much of my youth was spent observing life rather than participating in it. You’re only young once and I squandered many of my best years out of timidity.

I regret the times I was cruel. It may have only been a handful, but they haunt me. In eighth grade I told Susan that Tony wanted to break up with her. I did it out of the sheer joy of inflicting hurt on someone I didn’t like. Susan’s face fell before it remade itself into a mask of scorn. Then there was cruelty by passivity. I want to think of myself as someone who would befriend the lonely and stick up for those who were picked on, but I never did. I wasn’t the ringleader but I followed along, avoiding the friendless oddballs for fear they would contaminate me with their sadness.

I am happily married. I have a child who loves me and a good job. Everything turned out ok, I guess. And yet karma and philosophical conviction be damned, I have regrets. Plenty of regrets.

131 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?